Back Home About Us Contact Us
Town Charters
Seniors
Federal Budget
Ethics
Hall of Shame
Education
Unions
Binding Arbitration
State - Budget
Local - Budget
Prevailing Wage
Jobs
Health Care
Referendum
Eminent Domain
Group Homes
Consortium
TABOR
Editorials
Tax Talk
Press Releases
Find Representatives
Web Sites
Media
CT Taxpayer Groups
 
Home

Senate Resolution Cautions Against Federal Bailout of Fiscally Irresponsible States (Rachel Greszler / Heritage Foundation)

Rachel Greszler, Research Fellow in Economics, Budget and Entitlements July 9, 2019

 

The following appeared in Pension Tsunami which you might wish to consider checking daily or weekly!

 

Excerpt: The five states with the greatest unfunded pension obligations Alaska, Connecticut, California, Illinois, and Oregon have per-capita pension debts ranging from $28,000 to nearly $47,000. That is two to five times as high as the five states with the lowest pension debts, which range from $8,500 to $10,000 per capita in Tennessee, Indiana, Nebraska, Florida, and Idaho.

************************************

 

 

Most of the public was outraged when, during the financial crisis of 2008, Congress provided a massive financial bailout, including $70 billion of taxpayers money to insurance giant AIG and $80 billion to U.S. automakers General Motors, Chrysler, and Ford. 

Even most politicians who voted in favor of the bailouts did so begrudgingly, in part because they considered it a way to contain the damage from arguably unforeseen circumstances.

By contrast, state and local governments have accumulated many trillions of dollars in debt with clearly foreseeable consequences. 

If states want to make good on their obligations, many will have to drastically increase taxes, severely cut services, or default on their debts and lose access to credit. 

However, it is only a matter of time before state policymakers, not wanting to face those consequences, seek a federal bailout. 

That is why Sen. Tom Cottons sense of the Senate resolution (S. Res. 268), expressing the position that the federal government should not bail out any state is so important.

Considering that states cannot declare bankruptcy, many states failure to confront absolutely unsustainable pension and other obligations shows that they are counting on a federal bailout. 

In fact, then-Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn included a federal guarantee of Illinois pension bonds in his 2012 budget proposal. 

Cottons succinct sense of the Senate resolution says that the federal government should not take any action to redeem, assume, or guarantee any debt of a State and that the secretary of the Treasury should report to Congress any negotiations to engage in actions that would result in an outlay of Federal funds on behalf of creditors of a State.

As the resolution points out, every state in the U.S. is a sovereign entity with its own authority to collect taxes and to issue debt, with a legal obligation to fully disclose its financial condition to investors. 

Moreover, Congress has already rejected past requests for bailouts of defaulted state debt, and back in 1842, the Senate requested that the Treasury report any negotiations that discussed federal assumption of state debt to ensure that promises of Federal Government support were not proffered.

Although nonbinding, the resolution from Cotton, R-Ark., is important, because unless Congress takes a bailout off the table, lawmakers in fiscally irresponsible states will have the incentive to keep racking up more debt and taxpayers in fiscally responsible states would pay the price.

While all states have sizable debt, primarily from unfunded pensions and other public employee benefits, some have dramatically more than others. 

Take states estimated $6 trillion in unfunded pension promises. That works out to about $18,300 for every man, woman, and child or $73,200 for a family of four in America. 

The five states with the greatest unfunded pension obligations Alaska, Connecticut, California, Illinois, and Oregon have per-capita pension debts ranging from $28,000 to nearly $47,000. That is two to five times as high as the five states with the lowest pension debts which range from $8,500 to $10,000 per capita in Tennessee, Indiana, Nebraska, Florida and Idaho.  

If Walmart were facing bankruptcy Congress would not require Target to cover its payrolls. But that is what a federal bailout would be like by unfairly forcing taxpayers in states such as Tennessee and Florida to pay for pensions and other public sector workers benefits in Illinois and California even though they do not live in or receive any services from those states.     

The fact that governments do not face bottom lines is already problematic enough for workers, families, and businesses whose incomes seem like an open spigot for politicians to tax. 

Expanding lawmakers reach into the pockets of people they do not represent would only exacerbate what economists call moral hazard essentially the consequence of removing personal responsibility.

States that want to protect their current and future residents by getting their fiscal houses in order have plenty of options. 

For starters they can look to the sensible pension reforms enacted in states such as Michigan and Oklahoma that significantly curbed costs and to fiscally responsible states such as Nebraska and Tennessee.

While the federal government had no role in state and local governments debts it should make clear that it also has no role in paying for them.

********************************

Also read

News for Connecticut Pension Tsunami

 

Connecticut Police Department Reverses Course, Switches Back to Defined Benefit Plan (James Comtois / Pensions & Investments)

Bill Would Let Retired Municipal Police Collect Pensions While Double-Dipping as School Security Personnel (column - Jon Lender / Hartford Courant)

Connecticut Has Lowest Pension Funding in the Country, According to Report (Marc E. Fitch / Yankee Institute)

Three New Governors Face Three Old Pension Disasters (Brian Chappatta / Bloomberg)

Connecticut Confronts an Underfunded Pension Liability of as Much as $100 Billion (Ken Dixon / New Haven Register)

Connecticut Needs to Defuse Its Retirement Debt Bomb (op-ed - David M. Walker / Hartford Courant)

Connecticut Wants You to View Your Neighbors Pension. Here is Why (Lucas Laursen / Fortune)

Continue to check back at

News for Connecticut Pension Tsunami